|
Published on Sunday, August 15, 1999 - 1:43am |
|
A look at the American Dubbed MONONOKE HIME (aka Princess Mononoke)
Hey folks, Harry here. Right now... this very second, I see Robogeek's visual scanners scraping this page and.... suddenly... SQUELCH! That was the sound of Robogeek screaming. God I hope Claire Danes hasn't screwed this film up. After MOD SQUAD and BROKEDOWN PALACE I was ready to not see her on screen for a while, but if she has 'valley girled' MONONOKE HIME.... ARGH! I've seen this film undubbed and with no sub-titles and enjoyed the hell out of it. I've been dying to see the film projected, and personally I'd prefer an original undubbed, subtitled (written by Gaiman ala Anthony Burgess' subtitles for the Derpardieu CYRANO DE BERGERAC). Sigh... Oh well, maybe it isn't as bad as this spy let's on.
Hey Harry, Love the site. Been reading it since the buildup of Starship
Troopers, one of the decades best sci-fi. I caught a screening of
Princess Mononoke a few weeks ago here at a Sony Loews in Manhattan. I
haven't seen any posts on your sight and I just got the time so I
thought I would write a mini' for you.
Let me just start off by saying that I have no idea how this movie
became the top grossing anime in Japan. If you liked Wings of
Honnaimese then you will enjoy this film, if you are more of a fan of
action packed films like Akira or Vampire Hunter D, than you will
probably find this film lacking as I myself did. To sum up the plot, a
hero gets cursed, leaves his village, meets a couple of girls, some
wolves, and spends some time in a forest. There is the pretense of a
moral lesson dealing with nature and pollution but one would expect this
to figure in with the conclusion of the film. One of the biggest
problems with the script was that nothing was really in a different
place when the film ended then when it began. The head nemesis actually
states that she will do what she did again, and everyone goes along with
her. The characters were mildly interesting, including a forest god
that is just outright WEIRD. The animation however was excellent, top
notch, reason enough for some to see this movie..
The biggest disappointment for me were the voices. Claire Daines makes
the Princess sound like some reject valley girl. When she tells the
hero to leave the forest it sounds like a spoiled brat complaining to
her mother for more allowance money. Billy Bob Thornton put absolutely
no effort into this film, save for reading the script into a microphone.
His character is one of a wise appearing short guy, (not yoda like, but
more like a tricky leprechan) who pops up now and again throughout the
film. it could have been one of the funnier roles with some effort put
into it. Hopefully they would re-record the part, the character would
be better off mute than as it is. Minnie Driver and Gillian Anderson
were really good. Minnie was much better than in Tarzan she brought
grace and strength to her character, ditto for Anderson who had a touch
of synth added to her voice to add to her characters spiritual side.
There are some really cute ghost critters in the forest but if you hated
the ewoks then you will really despise these guys. Well I loved the
ewoks and I found these guys to be the best thing about this film.
Princess Mononoke does run a little long so I hope they cut something
else. Most of the others seemed to agree, really laughing out loud at
Claires sorely out of place vocal talents. I would say save your money
but if everyone goes to see this it will increase the chances of some
other great anime making it to our theaters, and God for bid we see a
decent Godzilla on the big screen.
If you post this, call me GayZilla
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Reader Talkback
I See... by Saluki | Aug 15th, 1999 03:01:53 AM | He smashes Miyazaki?
Sacralige! by Drath | Aug 15th, 1999 04:26:25 AM | I see you don't know much
about anime... by YellerDog | Aug 15th, 1999 06:39:21 AM | ^Spelling notwithstanding :)^ by YellerDog | Aug 15th, 1999 06:41:12 AM | Doubt it... by Prankster | Aug 15th, 1999 07:25:17 AM | Dubbing is the work of Satan by Briareos | Aug 15th, 1999 08:00:49 AM | about anime.... by GoreGroupieWhore | Aug 15th, 1999 09:04:23 AM | Harry, forshame! by Revelare | Aug 15th, 1999 09:33:44 AM | SNIKT!! by Gordian | Aug 15th, 1999 10:06:29 AM | DWD: Aw, Who Are They Kidding? by DwDunphy | Aug 15th, 1999 10:07:37 AM | And Which Valley Would That
Be? Nausicaa's? by Anton_Sirius | Aug 15th, 1999 10:13:15 AM | FOTNS/VHD better than Akira?? by nornradd | Aug 15th, 1999 11:00:08 AM | Maybe on video by maniacalmichael | Aug 15th, 1999 11:44:57 AM | Dubbing - a necessary evil by d'Artagnan | Aug 15th, 1999 11:55:15 AM | yecch! by JetAlone | Aug 15th, 1999 12:49:58 PM | Face it - subtitles are bad... by Wesley Snipes | Aug 15th, 1999 02:05:43 PM | The Mononoke dub by keeba | Aug 15th, 1999 02:08:11 PM | I agree with keeba by Canman | Aug 15th, 1999 02:50:20 PM | Disney and Miyazaki by Link | Aug 15th, 1999 03:39:50 PM | Oh, and one more thing... by Link | Aug 15th, 1999 03:47:35 PM | On Miyazaki and DVD by Kentobi | Aug 15th, 1999 03:53:18 PM | uh, I think you're missing the
point, Gunray by Godai-kun | Aug 15th, 1999 04:20:04 PM | Miyazaki vs. Linear
Storytelling by Dr. Duran Duran | Aug 15th, 1999 04:32:21 PM | Violence in Mononokehime by Izmunuti | Aug 15th, 1999 07:54:39 PM | Save me from the wanabe's... by Daswolfen | Aug 15th, 1999 11:33:12 PM | Subs not dubs by Debaser | Aug 16th, 1999 12:06:16 AM | Miyazaki=greatest animation
director of our time by Dave_F | Aug 16th, 1999 12:07:33 AM | Miyazaki Studios? by tv`snick | Aug 16th, 1999 12:32:10 AM | Have no fear...the movie will
rock! by BV | Aug 16th, 1999 02:01:26 AM | thinkin' about dubbing... by jb | Aug 16th, 1999 03:03:00 AM | Anime by maikeru | Aug 16th, 1999 03:29:40 AM | What, you were expecting Fern
Gully? by Albert Acisuan | Aug 16th, 1999 04:06:48 AM | dub this.... by DAS BOOB | Aug 16th, 1999 05:08:16 AM | Quite right, Debaser by Myrrhibis | Aug 16th, 1999 05:18:55 AM | Bad Reviewer by lynxcat | Aug 16th, 1999 05:22:53 AM | dubbed anime painful by G | Aug 16th, 1999 06:20:29 AM | Dubbing by Mike-F | Aug 16th, 1999 06:51:29 AM | Why Bother? by Anton_Sirius | Aug 16th, 1999 06:53:08 AM | awful review... by mckracken | Aug 16th, 1999 08:36:09 AM | anime, animation, and
dubbing... by JON1969 | Aug 16th, 1999 09:21:00 AM | The real problem with anime in
the U.S. by JBardin | Aug 16th, 1999 09:44:20 AM | Hehe. by Vanaja | Aug 16th, 1999 10:34:35 AM | Rock and Rule by CrusaderX | Aug 16th, 1999 11:26:31 AM | Miyazaki, anime, and
Monnonoke's ending by Palpatine100 | Aug 16th, 1999 11:30:37 AM | Montag606 by Prankster | Aug 16th, 1999 01:38:46 PM | Mononoke In San Diego by Salstadt | Aug 16th, 1999 02:30:19 PM | Montage, and Blah Blah. by Revelare | Aug 16th, 1999 03:41:56 PM | Revelare by Prankster | Aug 16th, 1999 08:00:57 PM | My Two Cents by The Great One | Aug 16th, 1999 08:57:52 PM | Good ol Ghibli stuff by Toranaga | Aug 16th, 1999 09:44:47 PM | I can't STAND
subtitles!!!!!!!!!!! by BV | Aug 17th, 1999 02:06:59 PM | Dubbing is a big part of
anime. by Wolfpack | Aug 25th, 2006 12:23:06 PM |
|
|