Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

THE IRON GIANT review V. 2.0

My first review for THE IRON GIANT was of an incomplete movie, some of the animation was still in pencil form and it had no soundtrack.

Well...

I’ve seen it twice in the past two days and I have tons more to say about this film since seeing it with two kid and parents filled auditoriums. Having watched my friends, my sister and my father watch this film. Listening to them and observing the look in their eyes as they speak of the film.

Nearly everyone behind the scenes here at AICN has seen the film at least once, some twice, and we’ll all be seeing it again this Friday (at least once, maybe more)

Every now and again we folks here at AICN are lucky enough to bring a film to your attention. Somehow, to seemingly discover the film. When we find one of these jewels, we push the living bejeesus out of it because something in the film illicits that pure visceral feeling of wanting the film to succeed.

Not all great films or classic films do succeed. Some bellyflop tremendously and that’s what I don’t want to see happen here. Why is this?

I’ve never met Brad Bird. He called me up, almost a year ago to ask me if I would remove early images of THE IRON GIANT from AICN, so that the character could be introduced in the course of the film. I agreed. That’s the last I heard from him.

My interest in this film spurs from the film itself. The movie is magical. The first time I saw it in that cavernous theater of Moriarty’s beneath the city of angels, I sat in a predominately empty theater. Maybe 6 people in attendance. It was very much like being alone.

Sunday afternoon I went to the paid sneak, took my father, hooked up with Barbarella and Olive Oyl and sat in a theater filled with families. Right before the film began, Robogeek, El Cosmico and Sabu appeared and took their seats.

The theater wasn’t quite full, but was about 3/4’s full. As the film began I felt a hush sweep over the audience. It’s a short little film. A little over 80 minutes, comparable to PINNOCHIO, SNOW WHITE as well as many classic animated films. While being oh.... 10 minutes longer than films like FRANKENSTEIN and the other Universal Horror films. My point is, a movie is as long as it needs to be, and THE IRON GIANT is perfect as is.

Each time I have seen it, the film has become stronger emotionally. As I begin anticipating what is coming, I inevitably try to steel myself from getting too involved, but try as I might... I just can’t help but be taken away by this film.

Tonight as I sat between Copernicus and the ever loving light of my life, Annette Kellerman I felt my bottom lip trembling and quivering. Tears were rolling down both cheeks. I caught Copernicus’ hand move up to his eyes, and Annette was knocked out.

The day before, I sat between Father Geek and Barbarella and all three of us were completely emotionally taken in by this magical film.

Now why? Why are we reacting this way? What is doing this to me?

Good questions, and I’ll try to answer them.

In regards to the Giant himself, this is a designed marvel. I’m not talking about him as a purely ‘cool’ design. He is. Point Blank, the robot just looks cool. But so does Robby the Robot, Gort, Tobor, C3P0 and R2D2.... However, I am finding myself incredibly attached to this robot more so than with those.

Why?

Sure the Joe Johnston design is cool, but what is doing this? I’ll tell you. This robot, this ‘big metal guy’ has a soul. When the little metal shutters begin changing the shape of his eyes, I’d swear this robot was smiling or weeping. We never see tears. We don’t see the smile. But in those lit empty sockets I see a soul.

I see a confused living being, a robot maybe, but the Iron Giant is living. The animators on this guy are nothing short of geniuses. Twice in the film I see the robot turn up his palms, motion frantically with one of them, whilst making uncertain noises. This is Karloff. These guys captured Karloff in this character. Later, he’s toying with a motionless thing... The way he touches it, pushes it, it recalls Willis O’Brien’s Kong.

This is the best animated creation I’ve seen since the height of Harryhausen’s craft. The creators give voice to the Iron Giant in a Ludo-styled baritone. And the sound engineering on him is a masterstroke.

One time while I was talking at length with Harryhausen he told me the secret to great animation of creatures.

My ears lit up, my eyes widened. “His secret” echoed through my mind. I felt as though fire was being handed to me.

Harryhausen said that a monster, a beast, a creation’s natural state is not as a monster or a beast. It’s not created to scare or terrorize. It’s meant to eat and sleep and walk and simply be.

He told me to watch the most viscous animals in the world. You’ll see them laying in trees, not set to pounce, but sleeping. Monsters sleep. A monster is only a monster to the one it is eating. To the baby creature in the nest, the monster is Mom or Dad.

And that stuck with me. It’s why Gwangi will scratch it’s nose or that Kong will play with something idly.

And here... The Giant can get bored, excited, tired and sleepy. The Giant can be hungry. But the Giant can care and love and wish to be something more.

It is that capacity to want to be something more than what he is that wins me. He doesn’t want to just be a robot. He doesn’t want to kill. He just wants to be happy and to exist. Simple things. But not in the world he’s placed in. And it’s that simple ‘fish out of water’ theme that wins me.

This is, with no doubt in my mind one of the very best films I’ve seen this decade. The film deals with controlling one’s capacity for violence, the meaning of friendship, the ability to look past the surface. It has to do with where the soul is and whether humanity is specific to humans.

I love this film. Not like those guilty pleasures you watch late at night. But with the same voracious appetite for love that you speak of a film that really and truly let’s loose with a spark of genius that catches ablaze into a full blown forest fire.

How does it affect kids?

All around me were children. And during the film I could hear them squeal with joy, laugh and giggle. When the film gets more intense I discovered something rather odd. I heard children reassuring their parents that everything was going to ‘alright’.

Tonight I heard a child tell their mother, “Mom, killing is bad.”

Another child asked their parent about the soul.

Great! Exactly what is needed and desired. After the film I ran into Glen and his kid Lil’ David. As always David came running up to hit me in my belly, and I shook my finger and told him, ‘Don’t be a gun David.’

He lowered his arm and looked at me. He smiled and went to run in circles screeching out, “I’m Superman!”

I’m sorry, but that’s beautiful. Of all the things to teach a child to want to be, Superman is as good a thing as any.

Finally I want to address the last third of the movie, and I’m going to do it in the vaguest possible manner.

The last third of the film transcends all that came before. It heads the story towards the conflicts you’ve seen in the trailers. But there is so much more that is still unseen.

I will not spoil this for you, but when you see it... I just want to give you my feelings on this. While what I’m seeing is infact some of the coolest science fictiony thingees a happening, I couldn’t allow my techno-fetish to kick in because what I saw repulsed me.

It was watching a soul disappear and turn into... an abusive loved one.

My mom turned into the gun for the last 7 years of her life. She became a very ugly destructive person out to destroy not only herself but all of those around her. She had sane moments, flashes of tenderness, but she had become a gun. She was no longer the person I loved, the look in the eyes was gone, the sound of her voice hardened and my mother was gone.

The ending of this film addresses that. And my god it is impressive.

The folks that worked on this film have my love and admiration. You people, you artists... You brought a bit of perfection into my life, and I want to share this with everyone. People I know, loved ones, strangers, fellow geeks.

I.. sigh.

In this world we have so many people that are guns. This isn’t about possessing them, but rather the instant lashing out that a gun brings with it. This should be required viewing by every family in this world.

The movie should become, for all time, a part of the familial unit. Families should watch it together and rejoice and learn.

When people now speak the name Brad Bird it should be with reverence. This is, purely and surely, one of the greatest films, animated or live-action, I have taken into my heart.

For me, I’ll watch it like I watch A CHRISTMAS STORY, IT’S A WONDERFUL LIFE, PINNOCHIO and BAMBI.

And that toy in my room. I look at it and I smile. It’s just a minor 15 degree shift in vision from this screen to my big metal guy and Hogarth. A mere 15 degrees to reach my smile.

Go see this movie. Take friends, pack em all up. Don’t let your day care take the kid first, go this weekend. The movie works on two different levels of watching. That of the child’s and the perspective of an adult. The movies are completely different.

By the way, if it seems like this week I’m talking a lot about THE IRON GIANT... well, the simple truth is.... I am pushing it like hell. I do not want to see this be brushed off as some sort of ‘also ran’ flick.

When I think that FANTASIA failed it’s first time out, I get angry. That film deserved to be heralded and succeed instantly instead of breaking Walt’s heart.

This film has to succeed. Why? Because Brad Bird must be allowed total creative freedom to create more works of genius. The Warner Brothers Feature Animation opening of this film should be reserved exclusively for Brad’s work, lest it be tainted by eyesores like POKEMON.

Go watch perfection this weekend.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

Well Said
by fatdan
Aug 3rd, 1999
02:45:10 AM
Thank you again, Harry. I'll never forget this.
by Nordling
Aug 3rd, 1999
03:50:04 AM
Iron Giant...couldn't have said it better.
by Ninja Nerd
Aug 3rd, 1999
06:14:43 AM
Just don't get too excited
by Martin Q Blank
Aug 3rd, 1999
06:59:53 AM
impartiality
by fonebone
Aug 3rd, 1999
07:15:41 AM
Harry, could a sequel work?
by Obscure Homage
Aug 3rd, 1999
07:27:12 AM
Wonderful, Wonderful, and most Wonderful and yet again...Wonderf
by Perfect Tommy
Aug 3rd, 1999
08:23:37 AM
Another bad review...
by 0007
Aug 3rd, 1999
10:20:24 AM
IRON GIANT............."A jewel???" MY ASS.......THIS FILM WILL
by quentin2
Aug 3rd, 1999
10:49:03 AM
Quentin2... what crawled up your bum and died?
by Cliff
Aug 3rd, 1999
12:37:52 PM
Great review, Harry
by Bryan
Aug 3rd, 1999
02:35:51 PM
Iron Giant & Quentin2
by claylori
Aug 3rd, 1999
08:58:41 PM
DON'T FORGET...
by Irie
Aug 4th, 1999
12:21:25 AM
Look deeper...
by Redbeard911
Aug 4th, 1999
01:17:33 PM
IRON GIANT's Message (**SPOILERS**)
by mrbeaks
Aug 4th, 1999
08:12:00 PM
iron giant
by filichia
Aug 4th, 1999
11:31:39 PM
Disney Passed on Iron Giant!
by Sammy Glick
Aug 5th, 1999
08:02:20 AM
"Film Student"
by tv`snick
Aug 5th, 1999
09:57:21 AM
I am laughing out loud
by Nordling
Aug 5th, 1999
03:59:29 PM
So your dad makes documentaries?
by fatdan
Aug 6th, 1999
02:08:18 AM
Roger Ebert's Iron Giant review...
by Ninja Nerd
Aug 6th, 1999
06:20:48 AM
WOW...
by Hooky Boy
Aug 6th, 1999
03:44:10 PM
man, I'm still trying to hold back the tears. I feel like a lit
by gaveltogavel
Aug 6th, 1999
04:39:10 PM
Best Picture of the Year
by darken
Aug 6th, 1999
04:48:13 PM
Iron Giant Rules
by HoseHead
Aug 6th, 1999
05:37:39 PM
Just right
by Dayth
Aug 6th, 1999
07:15:45 PM
your Iron Giant review
by Mikeoh
Aug 6th, 1999
09:35:27 PM
Hmm?
by Philip
Aug 6th, 1999
11:37:56 PM
Gonna get blasted...
by gilker
Aug 7th, 1999
07:23:15 AM
Gilker, I think you're reading too deep into this
by Nordling
Aug 7th, 1999
07:30:28 AM
Too deeply
by gilker
Aug 7th, 1999
08:19:05 AM
Harry, You Are SOOOOO Right on This One
by Sean Orca
Aug 7th, 1999
11:33:22 AM
hidden treasure
by voovoo
Aug 7th, 1999
04:49:09 PM
IG sets a higher standard
by Jiji
Aug 7th, 1999
07:39:05 PM
Iron Giant
by Stinkifish
Aug 7th, 1999
07:53:09 PM
Iron Giant
by Private Ryan
Aug 7th, 1999
10:09:29 PM
sickdogralph V 2.0
by gaveltogavel
Aug 8th, 1999
12:06:55 AM
The Hype Is True! A gushing report filled with adjectives! Read
by Funmazer
Aug 8th, 1999
08:04:04 AM
Fantastic!
by Tir Na Nog
Aug 8th, 1999
10:10:09 AM
I guess that means they're all on the take!
by ellid
Aug 8th, 1999
01:36:35 PM
Negative reviews
by realfan-3
Aug 8th, 1999
08:53:50 PM
GREAT MOVIE!!
by Sarcasmo
Aug 8th, 1999
11:02:03 PM
Bad Moon Setting?
by Armorham
Aug 9th, 1999
08:55:30 AM
HARRY, AREN'T YOU BEING A HYPOCRITE ???
by darius25
Aug 9th, 1999
02:59:54 PM
HARRY, AREN'T YOU BEING A HYPOCRITE
by darius25
Aug 9th, 1999
03:02:49 PM
The 5 best movies of 1999 so far (and all better than The Iron G
by darius25
Aug 9th, 1999
03:06:32 PM
It's only perfect because of computers, and maybe some pretty ba
by teethums
Aug 9th, 1999
05:38:03 PM
The Giant
by Phread
Aug 9th, 1999
07:48:55 PM
Stunned by the IG
by desslok
Aug 9th, 1999
09:21:45 PM
AICN HAS GIANTLY OVERRATED THE IRON GIANT
by FIDELIO
Aug 9th, 1999
11:15:51 PM
Ain't nothin' wrong with Pokemon!
by Agent 51
Aug 10th, 1999
12:09:39 AM
IG's Imperial March of Rockin Tasty Deliciousness
by Monkeyfish
Aug 10th, 1999
06:54:21 AM
Well said
by emorr
Aug 10th, 1999
01:03:57 PM
ONE MORE THING
by FIDELIO
Aug 10th, 1999
01:06:12 PM
Protect the future
by Mil1
Aug 10th, 1999
03:20:18 PM
Perfection
by NJFILM20
Aug 10th, 1999
07:58:40 PM
Dont criticize Harry's taste if your top 5 films of 99 include t
by ADNT13!
Aug 11th, 1999
08:27:49 AM
Thank GOD Disney passed...
by Kin
Aug 11th, 1999
08:38:57 AM
Tune in, turn on...
by MR.CHRISTIAN
Aug 11th, 1999
11:50:13 AM

by Shadow Lord
Aug 11th, 1999
04:30:29 PM
Just took my kids today: good movie, but WB really fumbled the
by Brendan3
Aug 11th, 1999
08:49:11 PM
to the converted
by tigerbus
Aug 11th, 1999
11:40:21 PM
It's over now and I have proof
by Cineman
Aug 12th, 1999
10:53:27 AM
WB Conspiracy to sink Iron Giant
by Mr. Ho Ho
Aug 12th, 1999
08:57:01 PM
That Giant Robot made me cry...
by nipper
Aug 13th, 1999
07:35:15 AM
Imperfect but nonetheless wonderful
by Incarnadine
Aug 13th, 1999
10:16:30 AM
Best movie I've seen in years
by treefrog
Aug 13th, 1999
01:04:04 PM
A FANTASTIC movie...
by rochambeau
Aug 13th, 1999
01:46:04 PM
iron giant
by suemouse
Aug 13th, 1999
03:40:29 PM
hardly a masterpiece
by budgreen
Aug 13th, 1999
05:40:42 PM
Deserted Theater
by Lord Shell
Aug 14th, 1999
06:04:27 PM
Response to maccabe
by Batguy
Aug 15th, 1999
02:01:16 PM
Iron Giant: Thumb's up from The Sith!
by Sith Lord Jesus
Aug 16th, 1999
08:02:50 PM
Dean Moriarty question
by MLS
Aug 16th, 1999
08:20:42 PM
MLS and the Kerouac question
by Brendan3
Aug 16th, 1999
10:32:38 PM
Thanks, Brendan3
by MLS
Aug 17th, 1999
12:40:26 AM
It was good
by funklord
Aug 17th, 1999
09:38:24 PM
Giant
by Calenril
Aug 18th, 1999
09:11:23 AM
Wow
by Rubel
Aug 18th, 1999
04:46:02 PM
I love The Iron Giant
by jwr
Aug 19th, 1999
03:56:56 PM
It works for all ages...
by jaxclone
Aug 19th, 1999
07:53:00 PM
Far from Suckage
by X-Ed
Aug 20th, 1999
09:17:08 AM
Bright side of bad Marketing...
by Phread
Aug 20th, 1999
09:55:58 PM
to "phread"
by spooks
Aug 21st, 1999
08:56:36 PM
Hi Steve
by cyt
Aug 22nd, 1999
10:30:13 PM
Another big fan
by limbo
Aug 22nd, 1999
10:40:31 PM
The Land of Oz
by NaLaR
Aug 24th, 1999
01:49:10 AM
I loved it, except...
by Daredevil
Aug 25th, 1999
02:58:00 PM
BOYCOTT "BROKEDOWN PALACE"
by SMACKAVELI
Aug 25th, 1999
03:23:54 PM
I wept like a baby!
by QuatermassX
Aug 25th, 1999
05:31:52 PM
Iron Giant Review
by 4pies
Aug 25th, 1999
11:13:43 PM
Love for the Iron Giant
by questman
Aug 29th, 1999
04:11:47 PM
The Capalert review
by LadyHawke
Aug 31st, 1999
02:56:42 PM
I FINALLY saw The Iron Giant...
by Agent Mulder
Sep 1st, 1999
07:30:46 AM
Saw it again last night...
by mondoz2
Sep 3rd, 1999
08:16:47 AM
iron giant
by NEO101
Sep 3rd, 1999
11:24:09 PM
Iron Man's Human Heart
by monolith
Jan 20th, 2000
05:33:08 AM
He just wanted to be loved.
by Wolfpack
Aug 19th, 2006
01:44:59 PM
good, solid movie
by just pillow talk
Jul 11th, 2007
12:01:50 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.