Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

What Do The Critics Make Of AMC's First Original Miniseries, BROKEN TRAIL??

I am – Hercules!!

"I hate 'Deadwood'! It's terrible!" Robert Duvall told Howard Stern two weeks ago while promoting his AMC miniseries "Borken Trail," which launches tonight against the acclaimed HBO western. While promoting “Trail” on the Howard Stern radio show, Duvall seemed to take issue with the acting on "Deadwood," or the accents the actors used, or something. I think he said something about only people in New York and Los Angeles liking "Deadwood." It was a little tricky figuring out where he was going.

(Walter Hill, who directed the “Deadwood” pilot, also directed “Broken Trail.” Was Duvall unaware of this? Did Duvall and Hill part on bad terms?)

The reviews are mixed on “Trail,” which stars Duvall and Thomas Haden Church as cowboys who rescue a handful of Chinese sex slaves.

Variety says:

… A slow-going cross-country trek, AMC's first original movie owes a considerable debt to producer-star Robert Duvall, who is such a pleasure to watch as to (somewhat) compensate for the leisurely pace. Modeled after the "Lonesome Dove" series, this earnest Western from producer-director Walter Hill finally arrives at a satisfying conclusion, although the narrative about taciturn men and imperiled women at times seems mired in mud.…

The Hollywood Reporter says:

… It's a Western miniseries with impeccable pedigree, memorable characters, breathtaking cinematography and a story that seems almost as if it had been put together by a committee. … the characters, though vividly and expressively portrayed, are not terribly well-developed. … Credit the skillful performances of Duvall and Church for endowing these characters with a depth and magnetism that go well beyond what was on the printed page. …

TV Guide says:

… what a pleasant surprise that when [AMC] ponies up (so to speak) for its first TV-movie, it ranks among the best I've seen in years. …Robert Duvall, notoriously denied an Emmy for Dove, could remedy that with his quietly compassionate, captivating performance as Print Ritter. …

Entertainment Weekly gives it a “A-minus” and says:

… a superior saga: Duvall limns a crusty character distinctive from his Lonesome Dove days; Church erases his natural wit and replaces it with beautifully weathered melancholy …

The Washington Post says:

… It was written, as readers of Thursday's Style section know, by one of Duvall's horse country buddies, Alan Geoffrion, and his lack of experience shows. His talent is for scene and character, not structure. The dialogue is often what might be called agrarian lyric and his characters always surprise with their quirks, their preferences, even their names (Big Rump Kate, for example). Yet the movie starts and stops, takes detours thisaway and thataway, abandons or loses interest in characters. The result is a dramatic mess disguised as a visual feast. Or, possibly, it's a visual feast disguised as a dramatic mess. …

8 p.m. Sunday and Monday. AMC.









Lonesome Dove: The Complete Miniseries $9.98!!
The Godfather $13.10!!
The Great Santini $6.99!!
Rambling Rose $8.99!!
The Handmaid's Tale $12.99!!
Falling Down $9.99!!
Apocalypse Now Redux $13.27!!
Days of Thunder $9.99!!



50% Off
All These Fox Sci-Fi Season Sets!!

Buffy The Vampire Slayer (All Seasons) $19.97!! X-Files (All Seasons) $24.97!! Alien Nation $24.97!! Angel $29.97!! Dark Angel $19.97!! Firefly $24.97!! Harsh Realm $19.97!! The Lone Gunmen $19.97!! Lost In Space $39.97!! Millenium $29.97!! Point Pleasant $19.97!! Roswell $29.97!! Space: Above and Beyond $24.97!! Tru Calling $13.47!! Find all the half-off here!!

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

Duvall is a man...
by VanLingoMungo
Jun 25th, 2006
06:22:29 PM
did anyone else get the first impression...
by tango fett
Jun 25th, 2006
06:33:57 PM
Duvall is an ornery fella, much given to the crustiness
by newc0253
Jun 25th, 2006
06:36:39 PM
No Sam Elliott?
by EyeofPolyphemus
Jun 25th, 2006
06:44:12 PM
Hell yeah AMC advertised the heck out of this...
by Shermdawg
Jun 25th, 2006
06:53:48 PM
I'm there!
by Azlam Orlandu
Jun 25th, 2006
07:08:03 PM
wtf? is this a movie or a series?
by punto
Jun 25th, 2006
07:46:57 PM
I'm with him about Deadwood
by Incomplete Gamer
Jun 25th, 2006
07:53:49 PM
Hey, Herc...
by CatVutt
Jun 25th, 2006
08:17:45 PM
punto, it's a movie broken up over two nights.
by Shermdawg
Jun 25th, 2006
08:51:31 PM
Decent, but few things bothered me about it...
by Shermdawg
Jun 25th, 2006
09:05:52 PM
Screw Bobby D
by topaz4206
Jun 25th, 2006
09:46:11 PM
I'll pass on Boo Radley, thank you very much.
by Shermdawg
Jun 25th, 2006
09:56:25 PM
Emmy series semifinalists pretty much set in stone...
by paulh
Jun 25th, 2006
10:28:29 PM
2005-06 Emmy comedy series semifinalists:
by paulh
Jun 25th, 2006
10:30:26 PM
2005-06 Emmy drama series semifinalists:
by paulh
Jun 25th, 2006
10:32:26 PM
And to show I didn't pull all that out of my butt... ;)
by paulh
Jun 25th, 2006
10:33:34 PM
I couldn't give a poop 'bout the Emmy's, but...
by Shermdawg
Jun 25th, 2006
11:50:11 PM
Ok, there could be a hitch in my predictions...
by Shermdawg
Jun 25th, 2006
11:59:07 PM
Where's the Cunt?
by RonaldLark
Jun 26th, 2006
01:04:49 AM
I like westerns that are dirty and unclean...
by ZeroCorpse
Jun 26th, 2006
01:11:25 AM
I tried
by VanLingoMungo
Jun 26th, 2006
01:23:17 AM
sounds nice and old-school, maybe ill catch part 2
by Freakemovie
Jun 26th, 2006
01:32:09 AM
Deadwood haters...
by lycanthrope
Jun 26th, 2006
03:02:52 AM
first!
by b3mike
Jun 26th, 2006
03:53:26 AM
Gwendoline Yeo!
by Hal2814
Jun 26th, 2006
06:53:04 AM
AMC plays crap like Home Alone 3...yea, THATS a classic
by tripp5
Jun 26th, 2006
09:39:59 AM
Robert Duvall sucks cock by choice.
by johnnyangel
Jun 26th, 2006
11:22:33 AM
Yes, I like it that they're American Movie Classics...
by tango fett
Jun 26th, 2006
11:44:02 AM
I liked 'Broken Trail'
by Guy Gaduois
Jun 26th, 2006
01:15:41 PM
There wasn't all that many commercials in it.
by Shermdawg
Jun 26th, 2006
01:35:15 PM
Maybe you're rigt Shermdawg
by Guy Gaduois
Jun 26th, 2006
04:17:08 PM
Guy Gaduois
by Shermdawg
Jun 26th, 2006
07:03:48 PM
Oh well, he'll be dead soon.
by I Dunno
Jun 26th, 2006
09:14:47 PM
That was a good mini-movie event.
by Z0D
Jun 26th, 2006
09:30:12 PM
Yeah, Open Range had...
by Shermdawg
Jun 26th, 2006
09:47:20 PM
Shoot Outs...
by Z0D
Jun 26th, 2006
11:04:32 PM
horse put down
by plurub
Jun 26th, 2006
11:05:00 PM
plurub......thanks.
by Shermdawg
Jun 26th, 2006
11:27:04 PM
Cute Young Chinese Women
by SeedyAl
Jun 27th, 2006
08:07:34 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.