Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

How Did THIS FILM IS NOT YET RATED Get An NC-17?!

Hi, everyone. "Moriarty" here with some Rumblings From The Lab...

This sounds awesome. Kirby Dick is one of the most consistently engaging and interesting documentarians working right now, as anyone who saw TWIST OF FAITH this year can attest. Today, I got the following in my inbox:

NEW YORK, NY, December 7, 2005 – IFC, the first and largest network dedicated to independent film, announced today that the IFC Original Documentary, “This Film Is Not Yet Rated,” from Academy Award-nominated director Kirby Dick and producer Eddie Schmidt, will premiere at the 2006 Sundance Film Festival and air on IFC in Fall 2006. The documentary, a breakthrough investigation into the MPAA film ratings system and its profound effect on American culture, is executive produced by IFC’s Alison Palmer Bourke and Evan Shapiro.

On November 30, the ratings board, an anonymous group whose mandate is to classify films for the MPAA from the perspective of “the average American parent,” screened this documentary and gave it an NC-17 rating for “some graphic sexual content.” An NC-17 rating generally limits a film’s avenues of exhibition: many theater chains will not show it, media outlets will not run its advertisements and video store chains will not stock it.

IFC, however, will present the film uncensored and uninterrupted. Alison Palmer Bourke, IFC’s VP of Documentaries and Features states: “Kirby’s film is a natural for IFC. Our 'tv, uncut.' mandate is to give filmmakers a platform for free expression, and we let our viewers decide for themselves what is appropriate and of interest to them."

Kirby Dick agrees, “It is important that this film be seen by as many people as possible, as it deals with an insidious form of censorship resulting from a ratings process that has been kept secret for more than 30 years.”

The documentary asks whether Hollywood movies and independent films are rated equally for comparable content; whether sexual content in gay-themed movies is given harsher ratings penalties than their heterosexual counterparts; whether it makes sense that extreme violence is given an R rating while sexuality is banished to the cutting room floor; whether Hollywood studios receive detailed directions as to how to change an NC-17 film into an R, while independent film producers are left guessing; and finally, whether keeping the raters and the rating process secret leaves the MPAA entirely unaccountable for its decisions.

The MPAA has established itself as the lobbying arm of the American motion picture, home video and television industries in the US since its inception in 1922. On its board of directors are the Chairmen and Presidents of the seven major producers and distributors of motion picture and television programs in the United States - Sony, WB, Paramount, MGM, Fox, Disney and Universal. When Jack Valenti became president of the MPAA in 1966, he created a rating system to replace the old Hays code, first adopted in 1930. Valenti’s voluntary rating system, modified only slightly over the years, has become an icon in American culture, with its letter ratings of G, PG, PG-13, R, and NC-17 (formerly X) used to classify films according to age-based appropriateness.

Until today’s announcement, the subject matter of “This Film Is Not Yet Rated” was kept under wraps by the filmmakers during more than a year of research into the MPAA’s rating practices. Director Kirby Dick (“Twist of Faith,” “Derrida”) interviews filmmakers, critics, attorneys, authors and educators. Ultimately, Dick tries to uncover Hollywood's best kept secret -- the identities of the ratings board members themselves.

Filmmakers who speak candidly in “This Film Is Not Yet Rated” include John Waters (“A Dirty Shame”), Kevin Smith (“Clerks”), Matt Stone (“South Park”), Kimberly Peirce (“Boys Don’t Cry”), Atom Egoyan (“Where the Truth Lies”), Darren Aronofsky (“Requiem for a Dream”), Mary Harron (“American Psycho”), actress Maria Bello (“The Cooler”) and distributor Bingham Ray (co-founder, October Films and former President, United Artists).

When Jack Valenti stepped down in September 2004, Dan Glickman succeeded him as president and CEO. However, Valenti continued to supervise the ratings process until September 2005, when the MPAA announced that it would be splitting its leadership duties between Los Angeles-based president and COO, Bob Pisano, and Glickman, who has been appointed the Washington DC-based CEO and chairman and now oversees the ratings system.

One of the things I’ve noticed is that the ratings board is one of the most reviled and misunderstood things about Hollywood, and the idea of this filmmaker taking on this subject is exciting. I’m not going to be at Sundance this year, but for anyone who is, pleasepleaseplease send us a report about this one. Thanks.

"Moriarty" out.





AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

The MPAA sucks
by Langfhir
Dec 7th, 2005
10:49:53 PM
first?
by Led Gopher
Dec 7th, 2005
10:50:44 PM
last
by D'Jesus
Dec 7th, 2005
10:51:01 PM
Ahhh...how ironic...or appropriate...or bad luck...whatever the
by Lenny Nero
Dec 7th, 2005
10:57:18 PM
THIS FILM IS NOT RATED should be banned immediately
by seppukudkurosawa
Dec 7th, 2005
10:58:42 PM
THANK GOD FOR THIS MOVIE
by scrivener
Dec 7th, 2005
11:00:10 PM
Slightly off topic, but this is what I call news!!!
by Vim Fuego
Dec 7th, 2005
11:02:06 PM
Saw Jack Valenti on the Daily Show this week.
by ironburl
Dec 7th, 2005
11:14:36 PM
The name is Dick...KIRBY Dick...
by themikejonas
Dec 7th, 2005
11:21:31 PM
Kids under 14 are filthy mouthed monsters no matter what you do.
by Lenny Nero
Dec 7th, 2005
11:22:06 PM
Maybe Because...
by FNORDcinco1
Dec 7th, 2005
11:24:54 PM
censorship?
by HillaryLovesMe
Dec 7th, 2005
11:26:05 PM
In Australia, we have a real man's "R" rating.
by Shan
Dec 7th, 2005
11:54:53 PM
Jesus Mother Fuckin' CHRIST, This Movie Will ROCK MY BALLS R
by buster00
Dec 7th, 2005
11:56:24 PM
The worst thing about the ratings system is that the art suffers
by jrbarker
Dec 7th, 2005
11:59:14 PM
What's this got to do with man on man oral sex?
by rivercb
Dec 8th, 2005
12:23:58 AM
My beef...
by BendersShinyAss
Dec 8th, 2005
12:35:51 AM
If nip/tuck can show Christian doing a fat chick from behind wit
by PVIII
Dec 8th, 2005
12:43:21 AM
"Pirates Of the Carribean 2" will be rated "ARRRRGGGHHHH!"
by Uncapie
Dec 8th, 2005
12:58:55 AM
I don't know about others, but I'm sure as hell not goin
by Lenny Nero
Dec 8th, 2005
01:17:52 AM
HAHAHAHAHAHA!!! FUCK THE MPAA UP THIER STUPID ASSES!!!
by DOGSOUP
Dec 8th, 2005
01:39:06 AM
ironburl
by Poacher
Dec 8th, 2005
02:07:16 AM
I no longer bother with so-called arthouse movies
by Thirteen 13
Dec 8th, 2005
02:48:18 AM
Thirteen 13, that's exactly why I like art house movies.
by Lenny Nero
Dec 8th, 2005
03:48:17 AM
Uh, Shan...
by Monkey Butler
Dec 8th, 2005
05:58:58 AM
Does that mean that you actually pay attention to those "age rat
by SalvatoreGravano
Dec 8th, 2005
06:09:04 AM
Theres this group that was on Showbiz Tonight tuesday, and they
by Shermdawg
Dec 8th, 2005
06:26:06 AM
So Mass Murder, State-Sanctioned Torture, Endless War, and Rampa
by ZombieSolutions
Dec 8th, 2005
06:34:32 AM
Ratings
by kuryakin
Dec 8th, 2005
06:40:16 AM
Incidentally -what does NC stand for?
by kuryakin
Dec 8th, 2005
06:42:36 AM
Lenny Nero.... why the hell not?
by BendersShinyAss
Dec 8th, 2005
06:43:52 AM
I was with you, BendersShinyAss....
by Citizen Arcane
Dec 8th, 2005
06:59:09 AM
I blame Paul Keating Monkey Butler.
by Shan
Dec 8th, 2005
07:15:57 AM
Theatres are supposed to enforce both R and NC17 (nobody under 1
by minderbinder
Dec 8th, 2005
08:00:17 AM
NC-17 stands for...
by Slim_Goodbody
Dec 8th, 2005
08:12:12 AM
up in the nort we're a lil more lenient...
by havocSchultz
Dec 8th, 2005
08:29:08 AM
NC-17 really means...
by delsol
Dec 8th, 2005
08:41:47 AM
The only thing wrong with the rating system
by godoffireinhell
Dec 8th, 2005
08:55:50 AM
I wish there were more higher rated movies
by Mr_Sleep001
Dec 8th, 2005
09:01:15 AM
The American rating system...
by dr_buggerlugs
Dec 8th, 2005
09:15:59 AM
The funny thing about NC-17 rated movies...
by fiester
Dec 8th, 2005
09:19:03 AM
Actually let me correct myself there...
by dr_buggerlugs
Dec 8th, 2005
09:22:12 AM
The reason why they accept violence but not sexual content
by performingmonkey
Dec 8th, 2005
09:29:33 AM
WHINER: THE MOVIE! I wonder if they cover the fact that the X-ra
by Negative Man
Dec 8th, 2005
09:31:55 AM
Recent article in UK Guardian wanted *stricter* ratings...
by tucson
Dec 8th, 2005
09:33:50 AM
The dilemma with censorship
by tile_mcgillus
Dec 8th, 2005
09:47:06 AM
I thought Eyes Wide Shut got an 'R'??
by dr_buggerlugs
Dec 8th, 2005
09:47:53 AM
dr_buggerlugs, Eyes had an NC17 rating at the AMC I saw it at in
by Negative Man
Dec 8th, 2005
09:51:52 AM
"the ratings board is one of the most reviled and misunderstood
by ComputerGuy68
Dec 8th, 2005
10:06:43 AM
funny story about a PG film...
by ComputerGuy68
Dec 8th, 2005
10:16:55 AM
ComputerGuy68, I too have a hatred of movie theaters
by JAGUART
Dec 8th, 2005
10:29:03 AM
RE: The dilemma with censorship + Requiem for a Penguin
by Negative Man
Dec 8th, 2005
10:31:19 AM
An example... The Merchant of Venice... R
by scrivener
Dec 8th, 2005
10:33:19 AM
The system is primitive and archaic....
by Engelhast
Dec 8th, 2005
10:40:51 AM
The MPAA is so hypo"christ"ical it's pathetic. It's no
by R.C. the "Wise"
Dec 8th, 2005
10:47:57 AM
JAGUART, ushers, oh I remember them...
by ComputerGuy68
Dec 8th, 2005
10:56:34 AM
Stupid parents...
by Engelhast
Dec 8th, 2005
11:01:44 AM
Butt rapeing Vs. Slimey Aliens
by BendersShinyAss
Dec 8th, 2005
11:11:51 AM
how about this for nc-17?
by Darth Pestilence
Dec 8th, 2005
11:16:07 AM
Fan-Boy, it's called CYA...
by ComputerGuy68
Dec 8th, 2005
11:31:11 AM
He said ride UP to the internet
by jackinitraw
Dec 8th, 2005
11:33:02 AM
The MPAA is a very good thing...
by Blacket-Man
Dec 8th, 2005
11:41:46 AM
So It's Okay For Teenagers To Watch Men Brutally Butcher Eac
by ZombieSolutions
Dec 8th, 2005
11:52:21 AM
Phoney__Bone
by scrivener
Dec 8th, 2005
11:58:35 AM
Three more examples of rating injustice...
by scrivener
Dec 8th, 2005
12:18:13 PM
I still wonder why the Matrix films were rated R...
by ComputerGuy68
Dec 8th, 2005
12:27:47 PM
Sexuality vs. Violence
by bralli
Dec 8th, 2005
12:32:12 PM
ZombieSolutions
by Sir Loin
Dec 8th, 2005
12:36:39 PM
"it is important that as many people see this movie as possible"
by devil0509
Dec 8th, 2005
12:43:12 PM
At Least It Beats The Hayes Code
by skoobyx
Dec 8th, 2005
12:54:49 PM
Just a quick question to dwell on: How sexually repressed are Ch
by Negative Man
Dec 8th, 2005
01:07:38 PM
Christian "control" of media
by bralli
Dec 8th, 2005
02:10:08 PM
The rule is..
by UES
Dec 8th, 2005
02:13:07 PM
if you want to piss off the mpaa and proud-crowd zealots
by ectocriminal
Dec 8th, 2005
02:47:40 PM
Anything he would never do himself (bloody violence
by TonyWilson
Dec 8th, 2005
03:15:46 PM
Meatbiscuit
by Engelhast
Dec 8th, 2005
03:32:18 PM
So what exactly is wrong with the ratings board? What huh?
by Johnno
Dec 8th, 2005
03:47:37 PM
Is it true
by Engelhast
Dec 8th, 2005
03:56:59 PM
Great marketing ploy by the producers and IFC
by Diskatopia
Dec 8th, 2005
04:07:45 PM
What the fuck is that Rambo doll?
by Groggy
Dec 8th, 2005
05:21:22 PM
meatbiscuit
by ectocriminal
Dec 8th, 2005
05:40:18 PM
Had a chance to meet Kirby Dick....
by Doom II
Dec 8th, 2005
05:55:09 PM
I like the NC-17 rating, but who uses it?
by Doom II
Dec 8th, 2005
06:07:06 PM
Ectocriminal
by Zauriel
Dec 8th, 2005
07:05:00 PM
The ratings system is nonsense
by MondoGundark
Dec 8th, 2005
08:46:07 PM
zauriel
by ectocriminal
Dec 8th, 2005
08:46:15 PM
whoa
by rabban
Dec 8th, 2005
10:20:05 PM
I Don't Think MPAA Censorship Is A "Christian" Thing...
by buster00
Dec 8th, 2005
10:58:17 PM
buster00
by seppukudkurosawa
Dec 8th, 2005
11:09:24 PM
"Conspiracy Theory" and why 6-year-olds should not watch "Pulp F
by MrCere
Dec 9th, 2005
12:42:44 AM
Pulp Fiction
by kuryakin
Dec 9th, 2005
05:32:00 AM
"I'm amazed by how little Americans know about their own mov
by minderbinder
Dec 9th, 2005
07:02:44 AM
Minderbinder
by Papa Lazaru
Dec 9th, 2005
07:59:17 AM
Speaking of Passion of Christ
by FlickChick
Dec 9th, 2005
08:30:04 AM
On Passion of the Christ...
by scrivener
Dec 9th, 2005
12:21:11 PM
Actually, NC-17 *isn't* "formerly X."
by darthferris
Dec 9th, 2005
01:18:50 PM
scrivener
by ectocriminal
Dec 9th, 2005
01:20:00 PM
ectocriminal
by scrivener
Dec 9th, 2005
02:51:31 PM
Engelhast
by Stubb-a-dubb
Dec 9th, 2005
04:22:58 PM
scriv, i have no personal agenda here...
by ectocriminal
Dec 9th, 2005
04:27:31 PM
In Australia we now have HUGE UGLY Ratings signs printed into ev
by Lutz
Dec 9th, 2005
06:21:01 PM
Also in Australia Art House movie crowd is urban professional...
by Lutz
Dec 9th, 2005
06:31:37 PM
There IS a difference between sexual content and violent content
by Daredevil
Dec 9th, 2005
08:47:04 PM
And all you railing about how these are "Christians" running the
by Daredevil
Dec 9th, 2005
09:55:16 PM
MrCere
by BendersShinyAss
Dec 10th, 2005
12:42:55 AM
Daredevil
by BendersShinyAss
Dec 10th, 2005
12:44:22 AM
BendersShinyAss
by Daredevil
Dec 10th, 2005
07:08:50 PM
Daredevil
by scrivener
Dec 10th, 2005
09:22:19 PM
How Did THIS FILM IS NOT YET RATED Get An NC-17?! The same way.
by empyreal0
Dec 11th, 2005
01:17:23 AM
Violence Vs. Sex ratings disparities.
by Hexus
Dec 11th, 2005
11:32:55 AM
Oh! One more thing...
by Hexus
Dec 11th, 2005
11:36:05 AM
How about if we put actors in fake naked body suits and THEN hav
by Lenny Nero
Dec 12th, 2005
02:41:41 AM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.