Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

Do we really need a WILD BUNCH remake? Warner Bros seems to think so.

Ahoy, squirts! Quint here. There are certain movies that are ripe to remake, like WILLY WONKA which wasn't exactly true to the book it was based on. There are certain types of movies that shouldn't be touched, that are perfect for more than just their story, characters and actors, but shot in the perfect time. You couldn't do a FRENCH CONNECTION remake justice. THE GOOD THE BAD AND THE UGLY is perfectly made in the perfect time with the perfect actors. It could not be made anywhere near as well today. THE WILD BUNCH is in the same league as those latter two films.

David Ayer is in final negotiations with Warner Bros to direct his screenplay remake of THE WILD BUNCH. I like Ayer. His writing on TRAINING DAY and U-571 was very solid. I hear his directorial outting HARSH TIMES with Christian Bale it very good, too. I am still radically opposed to this movie being remade. Especially since I read in the Hollywood Reporter that his remake is described as "a thriller involving heists, drug cartels and the CIA, set in contemporary Mexico." Why call it THE WILD BUNCH? That'd be like THE MAGNIFICENT SEVEN just calling itself SEVEN SAMURAI. Take the structure and make something new and unique with it. This could be an interesting failure, I guess, but I'd much rather see a roaring success with a film that takes note of the tone and structure of Peckinpah's classic than a remake in name only. What about you?



AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

do we really need a wild bunch remake?
by Andsoitis
Nov 4th, 2005
05:02:45 AM
Not Really
by Darth Bodie
Nov 4th, 2005
05:04:36 AM
It's NOT a remake!
by godoffireinhell
Nov 4th, 2005
05:27:52 AM
Do not remake Peckinpah
by siouxfire
Nov 4th, 2005
05:29:11 AM
IF ANYONE FROM WARNER BROTHERS MOVES... KILL'EM!!!
by workshed
Nov 4th, 2005
05:41:49 AM
The Wild Bunch is my fave western.
by deadguy76
Nov 4th, 2005
05:45:00 AM
Oh, but we DO need a King Kong-Remake, right!?
by kit-sung
Nov 4th, 2005
06:10:13 AM
Screw this
by Gungan Slayer
Nov 4th, 2005
06:11:26 AM
Wankers!
by dr_buggerlugs
Nov 4th, 2005
06:14:24 AM
Sounds more like a remake of "Extreme Prejudice"...
by iamthomas
Nov 4th, 2005
06:23:04 AM
Remake Need, Want, Blah blah blah
by siouxfire
Nov 4th, 2005
06:27:48 AM
Maybe it'd be worthwhile if they made it 3 hours long...
by Lone Fox
Nov 4th, 2005
07:44:15 AM
NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO
by ZombieSolutions
Nov 4th, 2005
07:51:59 AM
Although they're using the name
by DannyOcean01
Nov 4th, 2005
07:52:21 AM
This Sucks, But The Remake Possibility That Frightens Me The Mos
by ZombieSolutions
Nov 4th, 2005
07:55:00 AM
Cool
by Elkatak
Nov 4th, 2005
08:26:13 AM
new hollywood rules to get your film greenlit
by the_man_from_Rio
Nov 4th, 2005
08:59:24 AM
Why are we surprised?
by Boxcutter
Nov 4th, 2005
09:13:54 AM
Everything Will Be remade eventually
by Hate_Speech
Nov 4th, 2005
09:30:27 AM
If you gonna remake something remake the big one already! TGTBAT
by Judge Doom
Nov 4th, 2005
09:58:30 AM
no one can touch William Holden or Warren Oates these days --
by Spacesheik
Nov 4th, 2005
10:00:53 AM
As is usual with the remaking slime, this scumbag wants a "REMAK
by SalvatoreGravano
Nov 4th, 2005
10:08:37 AM
FUCK ME!!!!
by Chief Redcock
Nov 4th, 2005
10:11:20 AM
Reenactment of how a studio decides on which film goes into prod
by R.C. the "Wise"
Nov 4th, 2005
10:46:43 AM
Quint says:
by Film Whisperer
Nov 4th, 2005
10:57:12 AM
Stop Watching The Remakes- This si all our fault.
by Lovecraftfan
Nov 4th, 2005
10:58:51 AM
Lovecraftfan.... exactly what i was about to say
by mansep
Nov 4th, 2005
11:09:35 AM
Why this movie MUST be made.
by Fred
Nov 4th, 2005
11:29:26 AM
Fuck remakes
by CuervoJones
Nov 4th, 2005
11:30:33 AM

by Lovecraftfan
Nov 4th, 2005
11:33:25 AM
Que le den por culo a los remakes
by CuervoJones
Nov 4th, 2005
11:34:30 AM
Didn't EXTREME PREJUDICE teach anyone a lesson?
by Roguewriter
Nov 4th, 2005
11:37:18 AM
Oh, and if you must watch remakes, at least watch them courtesy
by SalvatoreGravano
Nov 4th, 2005
11:41:57 AM
Where do these studios execs get these great ideas from?
by IAmLegolas
Nov 4th, 2005
11:51:43 AM
sounds the worst idea ever
by zooch
Nov 4th, 2005
11:58:01 AM
I realize I'm being hypocritical because of KING KONG (anoth
by IAmLegolas
Nov 4th, 2005
12:03:27 PM
*sniff sniff* somebody smell sumpin'? *sniff-sniff* Why I
by www.valiens.com
Nov 4th, 2005
12:09:46 PM
I can see the cast now
by Phloton
Nov 4th, 2005
12:10:16 PM
Actually You Folks Snarking on King Kong Have A Good Unspoken Po
by www.valiens.com
Nov 4th, 2005
12:14:26 PM
not to post thrice but...sorry for the grammar in that last one.
by www.valiens.com
Nov 4th, 2005
12:16:26 PM
Drug cartels, CIA, Mexico.....
by bigbadbua
Nov 4th, 2005
12:16:54 PM
What happened to the R. Rodriguez Wild Bunch movie?
by martinsmith93
Nov 4th, 2005
12:57:57 PM
Just call it something else!!
by chickychow
Nov 4th, 2005
01:43:31 PM
plot
by Vindice
Nov 4th, 2005
01:50:52 PM
If anyone has to do it then obviously Tarnatino
by Citizen Arcane
Nov 4th, 2005
01:51:31 PM
Agree, let's hope this never actually happens
by Doc_McCoy
Nov 4th, 2005
02:01:11 PM
Welcome to the Suck,
by Proman1984
Nov 4th, 2005
02:03:51 PM
As has been stated,
by Moe Ron
Nov 4th, 2005
02:06:45 PM
I think there should be some kind of protection...
by SK909
Nov 4th, 2005
02:07:55 PM
bfd -- the original is perhaps the most overrated american film
by duanejones
Nov 4th, 2005
02:14:58 PM
"YOU LAZY BASTARDS!!!"
by Charlie & Tex
Nov 4th, 2005
02:27:23 PM
What's next? A re-make or 're-imagining' of THE GODF
by Orbots Commander
Nov 4th, 2005
02:33:51 PM
Well said, SK909
by Citizen Arcane
Nov 4th, 2005
03:02:12 PM
...ok I lost my shit on the typing at the end but you got the po
by Citizen Arcane
Nov 4th, 2005
03:04:20 PM
We only need a new Wild Bunch if it is a HARD NC-17 rating.
by Doom II
Nov 4th, 2005
03:05:18 PM
dumb
by reckni
Nov 4th, 2005
03:53:01 PM
Heh
by EyeofPolyphemus
Nov 4th, 2005
04:09:10 PM
"Sylvester Stallone presents a new 2006 reimagining of his belov
by JackPumpkinhead
Nov 4th, 2005
04:10:09 PM
By the way, competition time: name the noun that will replace "r
by JackPumpkinhead
Nov 4th, 2005
04:13:34 PM
Untouchable Properties
by Joey Cusack
Nov 4th, 2005
04:33:22 PM
No way it can top the original so they should screw it up just f
by Knobules
Nov 4th, 2005
04:39:47 PM
Re-make "Bring me the Head of Alfredo Garcia
by simulated stereo
Nov 4th, 2005
05:14:24 PM
Yeah, Change the Name.
by Evil Chicken
Nov 4th, 2005
05:15:17 PM
Wild Bunch remake
by mczcox
Nov 4th, 2005
05:46:55 PM
PSYCHO was remade by an auteur; did that justsify its exitence?
by Film Whisperer
Nov 4th, 2005
07:23:07 PM
Lame
by WONKABAR
Nov 4th, 2005
07:43:32 PM
Scarface - De Palma's one - IS set for a remake.
by JackPumpkinhead
Nov 4th, 2005
07:53:58 PM
Oh, and it's being "reimagined" as a game, too.
by JackPumpkinhead
Nov 4th, 2005
07:54:46 PM
Remakes
by Quint
Nov 4th, 2005
08:01:58 PM
I say remake the Star Wars prequels.
by Thirteen 13
Nov 4th, 2005
08:16:10 PM
Why not just re-release...
by REDD
Nov 4th, 2005
08:16:37 PM
I'm the only one who liked Dreamcatcher.
by Moe Ron
Nov 4th, 2005
08:21:49 PM
Someone should definately remake the Prequels
by white owl
Nov 4th, 2005
09:02:27 PM
"THEY?! WHY THEY IS PLAIN AND FANCY THEY IS!"
by Uncapie
Nov 4th, 2005
09:22:09 PM
Uncapie, You Sayin' You Have My Washers?
by Van Damned
Nov 4th, 2005
10:38:10 PM
Starring Wallace Shawn and Woody Allen
by cookylamoo
Nov 4th, 2005
10:44:07 PM
Man-dingo
by cookylamoo
Nov 4th, 2005
10:46:36 PM
Careful Cookylamco
by EyeofPolyphemus
Nov 4th, 2005
11:05:52 PM
Horror...
by psyclical
Nov 4th, 2005
11:41:36 PM
Van Damned, them's not washers, they's SILVER RINGS!
by Uncapie
Nov 5th, 2005
01:27:36 AM
Remakes, remakes, everywhere
by Capt. Spaulding
Nov 5th, 2005
01:28:14 AM
Spaceshiek check out "The Sons Of Katie Elder"
by Uncapie
Nov 5th, 2005
01:34:31 AM
Remakes
by Itblowstherobot
Nov 5th, 2005
02:01:20 AM
Peter Jackson's "love for the original".
by JackPumpkinhead
Nov 5th, 2005
05:06:53 AM
I say remake the pink panther.
by TheGinger Twit
Nov 5th, 2005
06:03:50 AM
Of course, this generation has to look no further than 'THE
by workshed
Nov 5th, 2005
06:08:22 AM
Hollywood HEART Money
by J. Pantsickle
Nov 5th, 2005
07:02:42 AM
William Goldman scripted DREAMCATCHER and it was still about ali
by Spacesheik
Nov 5th, 2005
11:28:42 AM
they remade PLANET OF THE APES, THE GETAWAY, etc - THEY ALL SUCK
by Spacesheik
Nov 5th, 2005
11:32:34 AM
yes uncapie, i couldnt believe that was a remake of SONS OF KATI
by Spacesheik
Nov 5th, 2005
11:36:21 AM
Wild Bunch
by DaddyP69
Nov 5th, 2005
12:09:32 PM
How to bankrupt Hollywood 101...
by Doom II
Nov 5th, 2005
02:05:09 PM
Insider info From the Other Side
by J. Pantsickle
Nov 5th, 2005
03:36:33 PM
If you have to remake a Peckinpah movie...
by whittier
Nov 6th, 2005
04:56:15 AM
They should remake KILLER ELITE and STRAW DOGS
by Spacesheik
Nov 6th, 2005
08:57:53 AM
You cannot improve Straw Dogs.
by HypeEndsHere
Nov 6th, 2005
10:45:49 AM
So true, Spaceshiek, so true...
by Uncapie
Nov 6th, 2005
11:00:33 AM
The Wild Bunch remake as the new Goonies?
by Vaguetam
Nov 6th, 2005
07:50:45 PM
Hey i got an idea
by Lovecraftfan
Nov 7th, 2005
10:39:08 AM
first!!
by Moon_Knight
Jan 11th, 2007
10:44:37 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.