Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

A Catholic & An Athiest review THE PASSION OF THE CHRIST at BNAT 5

Hey folks, Harry here... One of the reasons that I was able to talk Mel Gibson into giving me THE PASSION OF THE CHRIST to screen at Butt-Numb-A-Thon, a film orgy of cosmic proportions, was because of the audience and the way I choose them. Specifically each year I get around 3000 applicants for Butt-Numb-A-Thon. This year I had everyone write a little essay on why they wanted to come, their favorite films, what they do and who they are. THEN - out of those 3000, I pick the 230 people that are the most in love with cinema, that most need the experience of what it is I'm putting together. That need to sit next to who I placed them next to. That are the people that never get chosen for anything, anywhere... or that have amazing luck all the time. The point is to pick, the perfect film going audience, that comes to this tiny theater to see their hopes and dreams. They don't know anything specific. I often say, "Money doesn't get you into Butt-Numb-A-Thon, faith does." That isn't a religious thing, it's about having faith enough in the programming to do what it takes to get in. Mel loved the idea that only the owner of the Alamo Drafthouse and I would know that he and the film would be coming. That the audience would have NO CLUE that they were seeing this. He loved the challenge of his film having to be the last film on an 24 hour period of great cinema. And he wasn't afraid to follow RETURN OF THE KING. Below you'll find two people that absolutely loved the film, but came to the movie from radically different backgrounds. 1st is Saffy. Saffy met her husband in the AICN Chat Room and now lives in Houston with two daughters and was raised Catholic, but could best be described as a lapsed Catholic in some ways. Here ya go...

I don’t normally write reviews. Personally, I don’t usually believe I can because I become so emotional and I lack a lot of technical knowledge about film. Sure, I can go on a diatribe about the importance of Bene-tint to the way they do make-up in period pieces, or how Lucidity foundation paired with cool colored lighting casts an ethereal glow on the skin…but who the hell wants to hear about that? Well OK. Besides me and the cast of Queer Eye.

There are first times for everything, and paired with the first time I am writing a review was the first time I truly got to see what my emotional response to a movie was actually worth. I am going to review The Passion.

The visual look to this film was one part silent movie, one part mystic awakening and one part nightmare. It places you where you need to be, immediately uncomfortable yet familiar enough to go on. Visually this movie stimulates emotionally like nothing out there right now. It creeps…it doesn’t flash in your eyes, it engulfs. The camera doesn’t just film Caviezel, its star. It embraces and caresses him. Even in his darkest hour he expresses such a sense of knowing. Not the typical righteous stoicism we see in the usual film portrayals of Jesus, but a deep sense of spiritual knowing. So that even if you don’t believe in “the Jesus Story,” you can believe that Jesus was someone who possessed an inner quality of peace and forgiveness.

The story takes the Passion (something that I am very familiar with, growing up catholic) and makes it something I could never imagine: it makes it real. We see Jesus’ humanity. That he liked to joke, that he loved his mother, and that he truly suffered. Those turned off by the sometimes pompous, judgmental, “fire and brimstone” vision of Jesus will be able to remove the man from the religion that has built up around his followers. We also see in this movie the pain of his mother, a woman who doesn’t see the supposed blasphemer or messiah, but sees her only son suffer and die. The movie gives a heart to the most unlikely characters, the Romans. We see so much in this move, the political motives for the crucifixion, the dire position people were put in and how this story HAD to enfold like it did. We also see a more female vision of Christianity. The women were the brave followers of Jesus in this film, and were not relegated to a few weeping biddies on the sidelines. They were the ones begging for Jesus, stepping in front of Roman soldiers to give him comfort, the ones weeping at the foot of the cross. Mary, the mother taken off a two dimensional iconic painting and given soul and strength; something movies AND religion have failed to do.

Taking on a movie about Jesus that isn’t pontificating and damning you for all eternity for not believing must’ve been a task unlike any other. No matter what Gibson does with this it is going to offend someone. It has even started to offend those who have never seen it. But guess what? He still did it and he did it majestically. This isn’t an “Onward Christian Soldiers” film. This was a film about a man who spread a message that was misunderstood, and about the people who loved him. The anti-semitism buzz about the film, well I have to address it because there are things that I can see might offend if you don’t step back and realize that almost everyone in the movie is Jewish, from the Pharisees who condemn, to the Pharisees who defend, the apostles who fought, and the man who bravely picked up the cross for Jesus and held him in his pain.

I don’t know how critical I can actually be about this movie because…I wept. It hit me like an emotional anvil and opened up and healed many battle scars I have had with my spiritual convictions. I remembered through this movie that it was all about love and it isn’t the message that turned me off so many years ago but the way the message was presented. The message has been resurrected, the movie made it move and breathe, it made it real yet divine. This is art in its highest form, and even though Mr Gibson claims it’s not finished, it was, in my mind, perfection.

P.S.- Mel Gibson is ICE COLD. I had him all pegged wrong. He is an artist and a DAMN COOL GUY. Keith Richards…oysters…England…PRICELESS!

Ok... so now we move on to Abstruse, here's a sometimes chatter in the AICN Chat that in his initial letter to me to get into BNAT - he bemoaned the fact that he lives in a town where the only theater is owned by a right-wing Christian couple that won't let films like KILL BILL VOL 1 play. That he's never seen a film with a truly great audience and how he wanted to see films that he would never otherwise see. Now I learn he's an atheist to boot... here ya go...

THE PASSION OF CHRIST. Okay, before I say anything else about this film, I want to say something. I am an atheist. I do not believe in god, Jesus, or the bible. I am not a Christian, I am not a Jew, I have no religion. I am also a card-carrying member of the ACLU and a supporter of the ARA (Anti-Racist Action, a youth-based anti-racism organization formed in a retaliation to the neo-nazi movement). I have no ill feelings toward any religion, belief, or race. My best friend is Catholic, my girlfriend is Baptist, my soon-to-be roommate is a Deist, one of my close friends is a Wiccan, and two of my ex-girlfriends are Jewish. When you read this review, remember all this.  

The first thing I want to say about PASSION is that this is not a religious film. It’s a film. It’s an amazing, brilliant, incredible film. This is the film that everyone will be talking about in 2004. Unfortunately due to the press, they’re going to be talking about the wrong things.   

So far, everyone has asked me if I liked this film. I did not like this film, but I did not dislike this film. I did not love this film, and I did not hate it. This film is beyond those type of descriptions. I cannot say I liked this film. But I can say this is probably one of the most important films – if not THE most important film – of this century so far. If anyone wants to make another grand film, this is going to be the yardstick it’s measured against.  

This film is beautiful and ugly, epic and small. And this film is BRUTAL. Christians have turned the phrase “Jesus suffered for your sins” into a cliché. It’s lost all meaning by now. This film does an amazing job of making you KNOW what that phrase means. The MPAA is going to come down on this film like a fucking hammer, but Gibson should show it unrated if they tell him to cut a single frame.  

I can’t say this enough about this film. IT IS BRUTAL. There is no way make this clear without actually showing the film. This just cannot be described in words. You can’t call it violent, you can’t call it bloody. It is BRUTAL. That’s the only word. And it NEEDS to be brutal. It needs to make you squirm in your seat for an hour. It needs to make you want to scream at the screen for it to end. It HAS to do these things. If it doesn’t then you can’t understand the point of this film. This film has to transcend the human tolerance for violence and brutality to make its point. And it does. And it works perfectly.  

Now, the version we saw of the film wasn’t complete. The score was temporary, some effects weren’t there, and it was a rough cut. Therefore, I’m hesitant to even mention the problems I have with this film as they are all things which will most likely be fixed before it makes it into theaters. The main problem I had at first was the score. The music in the first fifteen to twenty minutes of this film is distracting. Again, since this was probably a temporary sound mix, this problem may not exist in the final form as the music may be much more subdued. The music, however, is very appropriate to the time period of the film, and after those first scenes of the film, the music is great. The only other problem I have is that I feel that the film could be much tighter. Again, though, this was a rough cut, so I can’t say it’s a real problem because a rough cut isn’t supposed to be exceptionally tight as an edit.  

My favorite character in this film is Pontius Pilate. You truly understand the position he was in. This was a man who was in charge of this situation, but didn’t want to be. He had a faction that was in power who called for man’s death, and a growing faction who that man led. If he sides with one, then the other will become violent. All he wanted to do was maintain the peace. So he tried to compromise many times. He tried to bribe the faction in power. He tried whatever he could. Finally, he was pushed to where it was either choose one side or the other, so he simply washed his hands of the whole incident. “It is not me who kills this man, but you.” He wanted that made clear. He wanted nothing to do with it, but they forced him into the situation. And it was beautiful.  

This brings me to “the controversy”. “Is this film anti-Semitic?” I have one response to this statement. “Are you on crack?” I feel this film is less anti-Semitic than the bible is. Gibson showed the Jews not as a religion or a people, but as a political entity. These weren’t priests of their religion, these were politicians trying to hold onto their power. The only reason someone could call this film anti-Semitic is simply to stir up shit for no reason other than to stir up shit.  

This film is amazing. It’s powerful. This film MUST been seen. It doesn’t matter what your religion is, this film is amazing. I just can’t express how important this film will become to cinema history. It doesn’t matter if you follow Jesus or Mohammad, Buddha or Moses, or no prophets at all like myself. This film has to be seen.  

The Abstruse One, Jason Byrons

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

Hello
by jjmnolte
Dec 8th, 2003
06:29:27 PM
The Jews killed Jesus...
by MxM
Dec 8th, 2003
06:32:04 PM
Interesting.
by Tesarta
Dec 8th, 2003
06:32:16 PM
Those of little faith...
by jjmnolte
Dec 8th, 2003
06:32:46 PM
first?
by Aragorn II
Dec 8th, 2003
06:36:33 PM
Congratulations, Mel Gibson, you have me lining up for this film
by FD Resurrected
Dec 8th, 2003
06:40:17 PM
People totally ignorant of the subject should not write historic
by RK100
Dec 8th, 2003
06:43:16 PM
No. I'm first.
by jjmnolte
Dec 8th, 2003
06:44:23 PM
The question is, will this make money?
by Stormin
Dec 8th, 2003
06:55:24 PM
RK100 - I'm with you
by Tesarta
Dec 8th, 2003
06:55:33 PM
Better than "Jesus of Nazereth"?
by riskebiz
Dec 8th, 2003
06:56:02 PM
And I know money isn't the point
by Stormin
Dec 8th, 2003
06:56:37 PM
A 19th century mystical anti-Semitic nun...
by Vlad the Rumpole
Dec 8th, 2003
06:57:19 PM
Anti-semitism?
by CaptBlood
Dec 8th, 2003
06:59:05 PM
MxM should be banned
by I_Got_Mad_Gritz
Dec 8th, 2003
06:59:23 PM
historical Pontius Pilate
by riskebiz
Dec 8th, 2003
07:01:55 PM

by raw_bean
Dec 8th, 2003
07:02:23 PM
RK100 I can't believe I am going to do this but...
by Sheik Yerbouti
Dec 8th, 2003
07:05:20 PM
oops, buggered that post up! Anyway, RK101
by raw_bean
Dec 8th, 2003
07:06:13 PM
bloody romans
by Danger Mouse
Dec 8th, 2003
07:08:56 PM
bloody romans
by Danger Mouse
Dec 8th, 2003
07:09:48 PM
Pilate
by FloydGandoli
Dec 8th, 2003
07:10:33 PM
The wall of propoganda is
by MxM
Dec 8th, 2003
07:10:53 PM
A question about the importance jesus' suffering and crucifixion
by HansDelbruck
Dec 8th, 2003
07:12:07 PM
The Brutality
by FloydGandoli
Dec 8th, 2003
07:15:55 PM
Hey Han's great question
by Sheik Yerbouti
Dec 8th, 2003
07:22:21 PM
*Yawn!* Who cares about this movie? I know I don't and let me te
by inkymae
Dec 8th, 2003
07:24:08 PM
This BNAT was Blessed.
by stuntrocker
Dec 8th, 2003
07:24:25 PM
post times
by Danger Mouse
Dec 8th, 2003
07:27:07 PM
They must have used "important film" a lot in the Q&A
by Gheorghe Zamfir
Dec 8th, 2003
07:34:36 PM
Perhaps the reviewer is anti-Semitic, or perhaps he just doesn't
by FluffyUnbound
Dec 8th, 2003
07:35:48 PM
what's really bothering me is
by Anomaly
Dec 8th, 2003
07:45:18 PM
Still waiting for the Buddist and Muslim reviews to come in...
by Bruce LeeRoy
Dec 8th, 2003
07:49:37 PM
ADL and antisemitism
by flipster
Dec 8th, 2003
07:55:50 PM
If Jesus Returned Today...
by Krinkle
Dec 8th, 2003
08:09:43 PM
not to offend...
by Yossarian
Dec 8th, 2003
08:15:56 PM
Guns don't kill Jesus
by chrth
Dec 8th, 2003
08:23:43 PM
Brutal?
by wideawakewesley
Dec 8th, 2003
08:25:01 PM
MxM
by Krinkle
Dec 8th, 2003
08:27:52 PM
MxM
by Krinkle
Dec 8th, 2003
08:31:01 PM
HEY GUYS MY NAMES HARRY KNOWLES. I AM GOING TO CONSTANTLY TALK A
by tycho556
Dec 8th, 2003
08:37:23 PM
Does the title of this article sound like a really bad joke to a
by TheSecondEvil
Dec 8th, 2003
08:37:36 PM
Once agin we have two reviews which blather on about the film's
by Mister Pink
Dec 8th, 2003
08:38:21 PM
Plus,
by TheSecondEvil
Dec 8th, 2003
08:39:22 PM
@ bjarki56
by chrth
Dec 8th, 2003
08:42:54 PM
Interesting discussion, so far...
by Moonwatcher
Dec 8th, 2003
08:43:00 PM
Heya RK100
by micben1
Dec 8th, 2003
08:49:57 PM
Why the film is not anti-semetic
by Vegas
Dec 8th, 2003
08:56:43 PM
check the passion
by anaelmasri
Dec 8th, 2003
09:24:56 PM
That motherfucker must have been getting a nice blowjob from a g
by tequilaworm
Dec 8th, 2003
10:08:42 PM
Nathaniel Brandon, Ayn Rand
by Anal Inflictor
Dec 8th, 2003
10:10:54 PM
A quandry
by mascan
Dec 8th, 2003
10:12:36 PM
Catholics aren't taught to hate Jews...
by JMM-MUK
Dec 8th, 2003
10:21:02 PM
Thanks Harry, Saffy, and Abstruse...
by viola123
Dec 8th, 2003
10:21:35 PM
Answer to HansDelbruck
by darthhaole
Dec 8th, 2003
10:29:30 PM
Good Ganesh!
by Boba Feet
Dec 8th, 2003
11:00:43 PM
Hey! What the Fuck??
by Boba Feet
Dec 8th, 2003
11:03:09 PM
Mr. Pink is back...
by CaptainHendry
Dec 8th, 2003
11:10:08 PM
Making a movie about Jesus is a cheap way to get people into the
by Holly_Wight
Dec 8th, 2003
11:13:55 PM
sources, and pilate
by Tesarta
Dec 8th, 2003
11:55:05 PM
Answer to Yossarian
by darthhaole
Dec 9th, 2003
12:02:57 AM
Douglas Adams has it right...
by Nickdude77
Dec 9th, 2003
12:15:05 AM
But do they explain why people think he was crucified?
by Rcamacho2278
Dec 9th, 2003
12:20:16 AM
anti-semitism.. bs
by hector
Dec 9th, 2003
12:41:40 AM
Science Speaks
by ShiFty_BoY
Dec 9th, 2003
01:55:31 AM
Holly Wight and other naysayers...
by TheDangerMan
Dec 9th, 2003
01:56:10 AM
(humbled) sorry..."four numbers"
by TheDangerMan
Dec 9th, 2003
02:03:52 AM
Doesn't anyone ever stop to think...
by Daryl van Horn
Dec 9th, 2003
03:22:55 AM
Doesn't anyone stop to wonder....
by Daryl van Horn
Dec 9th, 2003
03:24:13 AM
flipster...
by DocPazuzu
Dec 9th, 2003
03:32:18 AM
Email me if you have problems you chickenshit bastards
by TheAbstruseOne
Dec 9th, 2003
05:12:28 AM
Obviously The Passion is a cash in on the whole Kill Bill money-
by Magnus_Steele
Dec 9th, 2003
05:28:46 AM
4 very different gospels...you shmuck
by TheAquabatman
Dec 9th, 2003
05:54:11 AM
4 very different gospels...you shmuck
by TheAquabatman
Dec 9th, 2003
06:10:28 AM
Jason Byrons, reviewer.
by kultur
Dec 9th, 2003
06:44:14 AM
Abstruse is Abstruse@cpe-24-174-234-28.gt. rr.com * Jason Byrons
by kultur
Dec 9th, 2003
06:51:28 AM
Hmmmmm a Mel Gibson film.
by nervous twitch
Dec 9th, 2003
06:59:23 AM
Barrabas
by JohnnyAlpha
Dec 9th, 2003
09:03:24 AM
I thought....
by Jon Zuckerman
Dec 9th, 2003
09:38:51 AM
I thought......
by Jon Zuckerman
Dec 9th, 2003
09:39:56 AM
Reading all the reviews on this site so far reminds me...
by numberface
Dec 9th, 2003
09:56:30 AM
You know who killed Jesus?
by Wee Willie
Dec 9th, 2003
09:58:15 AM
atheism is a religion
by Mr. Impossible
Dec 9th, 2003
10:12:08 AM
the problem with films...
by boohallsmalls
Dec 9th, 2003
10:20:13 AM
check this out..
by Octaveaeon
Dec 9th, 2003
10:22:25 AM
There are NO prophesies of Jesus in the OT!!!
by Mister Pink
Dec 9th, 2003
10:47:25 AM
Hey Mr. Impossible...The word 'Atheism' itself MEANS 'without th
by HansDelbruck
Dec 9th, 2003
11:29:59 AM
omission of GREEK language- big error
by leonidas300
Dec 9th, 2003
12:02:44 PM
There's that word again...
by DarthCorleone
Dec 9th, 2003
12:55:17 PM
Good to see this kind of review
by Sanji
Dec 9th, 2003
02:43:58 PM
you can't use OT as an acronym for "Old testament" on this site
by Yossarian
Dec 9th, 2003
03:02:20 PM
Jesus Died For God's Sins
by alithere
Dec 9th, 2003
03:20:25 PM
Hey Aquabatman, ignorant much?
by Daryl van Horn
Dec 9th, 2003
04:22:08 PM
A Rebuttal to the comment "The Jews Killed Jesus"
by reidja01
Dec 9th, 2003
06:36:59 PM
The Greatest Story Ever Told
by DansLaLuna
Dec 9th, 2003
07:28:58 PM
My post was deleted???
by gurglesnap
Dec 9th, 2003
08:13:41 PM
Oh, it WASN'T deleted. It's just that I am a moron.
by gurglesnap
Dec 9th, 2003
08:17:04 PM
HELLOOOO
by calraees
Dec 9th, 2003
11:55:08 PM
Reply to Sheikh Boosteezi
by calraees
Dec 10th, 2003
01:51:11 AM
Apologies to Yerbouti
by calraees
Dec 10th, 2003
03:06:36 AM
Just two things to add.
by Sepulchrave
Dec 10th, 2003
03:37:32 AM
Response to Hans
by Bighonkin
Dec 10th, 2003
06:11:54 PM
Censor
by Damer1
Dec 10th, 2003
08:07:47 PM
A polite question I have to Jews about their religion (or race?)
by OingoBoingoBoy
Dec 10th, 2003
08:40:57 PM
Bible - Fact or Fiction??
by jeffp
Dec 20th, 2003
09:15:00 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.