Home Cool News Coaxial Reviews Zone Chat Contact Us Sign in

HERC Reviews ENTERPRISE 1.9!!

Enterprise 1.9 FAQ

What’s it called?

“Civilization.”

What does Herc secretly call this episode when no one is looking?

“Ugh! Let's See What That Bowling-Alley Lawyer Is Up To!"

Who’s responsible?

Teleplay is credited to Phyllis Strong & Mike Sussman (authors of “Strange New World” – the one with the lame transporter mishap).

What does TV Guide say?

“Disguised as locals, Archer and his expedition explore a civilization bedeviled by a virulent ailment possibly linked to a covert - and anomalous - nuclear reactor. Determined to find the truth, the captain teams up with a local apothecary (Diane DiLascio), leading to a close encounter between the two.”

Does Archer get pregnant?

Nope.

What is TV Guide not telling us?

There is no nuclear reactor. It’s a matter-antimatter reactor. TV Guide is such a liar!

Lots of continuity this week?

Virtually none. This one stands alone to the point of tearful annoyance.

Is T’Pol back to being a wet blanket?

Very much so. She wants to do all their investigating of this new civilization from orbit. “It’s standard protocol to wait until a society develops warp drive before initiating first contact.”

Does everyone disregard T’Pol’s advice?

To a degree. “Those are Vulcan protocols, not human,” points out Trip. Still, they explore disguised as locals.

Does T’Pol get all jealous when Archer smooches the local?

In no way. But when they go undercover, we do get to see Jolene Blalock trying out a new ear-camouflaging hairstyle.

What’s with that reactor?

A lizard-dude disguised as a local shopkeeper claims the reactor beneath his shop powers a device that allows him to fabricate food and clothing.

What does it really do?

It powers an impressive looking Viridium Isotope mining operation. But highly toxic industrial lubricant leaking from the reactor into the water supply is killing the locals.

Viridium Isotope?

It’s useful in the manufacture of explosives.

Any sign of Porthos?

He’s mentioned, but remains off-camera.

What’s good?

T’Pol advising Archer to “enjoy his tea.”

What’s not so good?

This turns out to be one pedestrian installment, with the fistfights and the shootouts and the break-ins. Where are the Archons when you need them? I'd even settle for a Ferengi.

How does it end, spoiler boy?

We witness a tender farewell between Archer and his medieval alien Erin Brockovich.

Herc’s rating for “Enterprise” 1.9?

**

The Hercules T. Strong Rating System:

  • ***** better than we deserve
  • **** better than most motion pictures
  • *** actually worth your valuable time
  • ** as horrible as most stuff on TV
  • * makes you quietly pray for bulletins

I warn you not to defy me!! Mmm cookies!!

I am – Hercules!!





To order coffee mugs and boxer shorts adorned with the image of a green, handicapable “Buffy” fanatic, click here.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Click for previous story Talk Back More on this story Click for next story

User login

Reader Talkback

Not surprised this one isn't reviewed well
by flowergirl
Nov 14th, 2001
03:42:26 AM
THE PREDICTION
by CaptainMisery
Nov 14th, 2001
03:51:25 AM
Noooooo
by It's A Duck
Nov 14th, 2001
05:16:36 AM
Remember, ST TNG Sucked Big Time (at first)
by McBUGDoc
Nov 14th, 2001
11:38:16 AM
Silly Putty Aliens
by tbrosz
Nov 14th, 2001
11:56:31 AM
Prose and Cons
by jtownsel
Nov 14th, 2001
12:32:08 PM
the season-ending cliffhanger *must* end with Archer saying "Oh
by durhay
Nov 14th, 2001
12:36:14 PM
Love on the Enterprise
by Electric_Monk
Nov 14th, 2001
01:25:40 PM
What's with the Farscape worship? That series is terrible
by flowergirl
Nov 14th, 2001
01:27:10 PM
The "Lets give it a year to develop" argument does not hold wate
by Xocxoc
Nov 14th, 2001
01:29:05 PM
Flowergirl, Farscape is...
by SimonSezz
Nov 14th, 2001
02:29:06 PM
"sucking aready"?
by usagibrian
Nov 14th, 2001
02:42:31 PM
This + Battlestar Galactica Revival = Death of Sci Fi
by PencilSharp
Nov 14th, 2001
02:57:00 PM
Question for Herc or whoever ele has seen it
by humboldt99
Nov 14th, 2001
03:25:05 PM
The next ST?
by GPL Racer
Nov 14th, 2001
05:03:27 PM
Thanks Herc
by humboldt99
Nov 14th, 2001
05:05:21 PM
Trip's the best character on the show...
by Sgt. Bilko
Nov 14th, 2001
05:05:58 PM
Jolene Blalock = DITZ!!!!!!!
by Skippy
Nov 14th, 2001
05:42:05 PM
Barzit Is Right
by Barron34
Nov 14th, 2001
05:59:23 PM
Let me get this straight....as I attempt to quell my laughter
by flowergirl
Nov 14th, 2001
06:18:54 PM
nah flowergirl
by kojiro
Nov 14th, 2001
08:23:57 PM
Trek and Sucking!
by Lukecash
Nov 14th, 2001
08:26:36 PM
flowergirl...
by Choda Boy
Nov 14th, 2001
08:32:06 PM
Oooops
by Choda Boy
Nov 14th, 2001
08:37:34 PM
UTTER BLASPHEMY...
by Weasel
Nov 14th, 2001
09:20:37 PM
Great idea! Maybe!
by scot_free
Nov 14th, 2001
09:36:00 PM
FOR SCOT FREE...
by Weasel
Nov 14th, 2001
09:46:48 PM
Hey, at least Archer didn't writhe in pain
by vladvampire
Nov 14th, 2001
10:38:27 PM
My weekly defense of Enterprise
by Hardyboy
Nov 14th, 2001
10:45:42 PM
V Guys
by Knumbersix
Nov 14th, 2001
10:46:12 PM
To boldy go again where no-one's gone before
by corvette63
Nov 14th, 2001
10:57:23 PM
This episode wasn't the best, but it was decent. Herc, mayb
by Z0D
Nov 14th, 2001
11:05:03 PM
And what did we learn today, kiddies?
by superninja
Nov 15th, 2001
12:06:33 AM
Voyagerish
by Prof. Pop-Cult
Nov 15th, 2001
12:14:38 AM
The Current Status Of Sci-Fi
by jcasnaw
Nov 15th, 2001
12:14:38 AM
Don't touch the OG...my Star Trek, the Original Series.
by superninja
Nov 15th, 2001
12:58:03 AM
And while I'm on the subject, flowergirl hit the nail on the
by superninja
Nov 15th, 2001
01:06:58 AM
Saw the ep. Not great, but better than Herc implied.
by flowergirl
Nov 15th, 2001
01:24:36 AM
Trip......
by flowergirl
Nov 15th, 2001
01:33:46 AM
continuity - "tellarites"
by pasquino
Nov 15th, 2001
02:31:34 AM
I can't believe nobody's mentioned...
by infallible
Nov 15th, 2001
04:25:14 AM
WHY DOESN'T TRIP CALL OUT T'POL ON THE ILLOGIC OF BEAST
by billy_zardus
Nov 15th, 2001
05:06:40 AM
Linda Park
by NNNOOO!!!
Nov 15th, 2001
07:08:22 AM
In agreement on Linda Park
by kdoc13
Nov 15th, 2001
08:00:04 AM
It's not blasphemy - Bring back the old series!
by dkmonroe
Nov 15th, 2001
09:04:21 AM
Thank you.
by White_Noise
Nov 15th, 2001
09:31:02 AM
WELL SAID, DKMONROE...
by Weasel
Nov 15th, 2001
11:36:41 AM
Boring
by Knobules
Nov 15th, 2001
11:43:05 AM
I liked this episode.
by atomic-bananas
Nov 15th, 2001
11:51:54 AM
I am GLAD its not like the West Wing.
by atomic-bananas
Nov 15th, 2001
11:58:50 AM
I didn't mean that ST should mimic the politics of "West Win
by dkmonroe
Nov 15th, 2001
12:33:17 PM
it could have been worse
by KennethV
Nov 15th, 2001
03:08:22 PM
What Herc Forgot to Mention
by Lukecash
Nov 15th, 2001
03:57:43 PM
Enterprise is Great
by Trapper Markelz
Nov 15th, 2001
05:19:21 PM
I said it once, I'll say it again: ENTERPRISE IS VOYAGERIFIC
by AtomoPrime
Nov 15th, 2001
07:00:29 PM
Why must we reverse-engineer apologies for bad science?
by No-Op
Nov 15th, 2001
07:02:30 PM
Nothing compares to Farscape
by orac_uk
Nov 15th, 2001
07:37:14 PM
The Maulurians couldn't transport because of the dampening f
by flowergirl
Nov 15th, 2001
08:11:37 PM
nitpickers anonymous
by KennethV
Nov 15th, 2001
08:45:57 PM
'Pure cheese'
by orac_uk
Nov 15th, 2001
09:11:53 PM
well, you certainly told me
by flowergirl
Nov 15th, 2001
09:51:27 PM
Flowergirl, Pay attention if you're going to bash a plot hol
by No-Op
Nov 15th, 2001
10:21:20 PM
*oh dear*
by flowergirl
Nov 15th, 2001
10:40:01 PM
to flowergirl et al
by Knumbersix
Nov 16th, 2001
12:25:00 AM
here, here, Knumbersix
by KennethV
Nov 16th, 2001
02:16:56 AM
excuses?
by flowergirl
Nov 16th, 2001
04:06:44 AM
In Defense of FlowerGirl
by Lukecash
Nov 16th, 2001
04:39:21 AM
TOS and this
by AcidJokers
Nov 16th, 2001
09:35:28 AM
When I said season I meant series.
by AcidJokers
Nov 16th, 2001
09:36:52 AM
Futility
by Knumbersix
Nov 16th, 2001
09:39:52 AM
Futility
by Knumbersix
Nov 16th, 2001
09:58:50 AM
Thank you Luke Cash
by flowergirl
Nov 16th, 2001
01:06:24 PM
Numbersix-just to clear up
by Lukecash
Nov 16th, 2001
01:34:37 PM
Plot holes (and where can I get one of them BEAST IMPLANTS?)
by tbrosz
Nov 16th, 2001
01:39:35 PM
flowergirl, flowergirl, flowergirl ...
by Knumbersix
Nov 16th, 2001
01:41:06 PM
Spoon!
by General Idea
Nov 16th, 2001
02:19:50 PM

Quick Talkback

Please login to post talkback.